svemagie/Substrate
1
0
Fork 0
Code Issues Pull Requests Actions Packages Projects Releases Wiki Activity
Files
main
Substrate/KNOWLEDGE-GRAPH.md
svemagie 87a5c2ba85 feat: add DE Lobbyregister as data source DS-00011 
Lobbyregistergesetz (2022) mandatory register for Bundestag/Bundesregierung lobbying.
Connected to PR-00002 (Illegitimate Domination) and PR-00005 (Epistemic Power).
Includes quality assessment, API access notes, potential future metrics,
and cross-links to OR-00004 (Mehr Demokratie) and OR-00005 (netzpolitik.org).

Co-Authored-By: Claude Sonnet 4.6 <noreply@anthropic.com>
2026-04-18 22:43:09 +02:00

183 lines
8.7 KiB
Markdown
Raw Permalink Blame History

This file contains ambiguous Unicode characters
This file contains Unicode characters that might be confused with other characters. If you think that this is intentional, you can safely ignore this warning. Use the Escape button to reveal them.
# Substrate Knowledge Graph
**Last Updated:** 2026-04-18
**Purpose:** Complete relationship map of all Substrate components — for AI analysis, human navigation, and cross-reference verification.
---
## Component Inventory
| Category | Count | IDs |
|----------|-------|-----|
| Problems | 7 | PR-00001–PR-00007 |
| Models | 5 | MO-00001–MO-00005 |
| Values | 6 | VA-00001–VA-00006 |
| Arguments | 4 | AR-12934, AR-00001–AR-00003 |
| Organizations | 5 | OR-00001–OR-00005 |
| Plans | 2 | us-plan1-miessler, de-plan1-sven |
| Data | 8 | DE-Common-Metrics, US-Common-Metrics, DE-Democracy-Metrics, US-GDP, US-Inflation, US-Presidential-Approval, Bay-Area-COVID-Wastewater, Knowledge-Worker-Global-Salaries |
| Data Sources | 11 | DS-00001–DS-00010 (US/Global), DS-00011 (DE Lobbyregister) |
---
## Problems → Connected Components
### PR-00001 — Meaning Crisis
- **Models explaining:** MO-00001 (Han), MO-00004 (Vervaeke)
- **Values responding:** VA-00006 (Deep Reflection As Practice)
- **Arguments:** —
- **Organizations:** —
- **Plans:** de-plan1-sven (CHALLENGE 4 — exhaustion/withdrawal)
- **Related Problems:** PR-00003 (Exhaustion), PR-00004 (Fascization — meaning loss as precondition)
### PR-00002 — Illegitimate Domination
- **Models explaining:** MO-00005 (Graeber/Anarchism)
- **Values responding:** VA-00002 (Authority Requires Justification), VA-00004 (Mutual Aid Over Market)
- **Arguments:** —
- **Organizations:** OR-00004 (Mehr Demokratie), OR-00005 (netzpolitik)
- **Plans:** de-plan1-sven (CHALLENGE 1, 2)
- **Data Sources:** DS-00011 (DE Lobbyregister — makes visible who translates money into political power)
- **Related Problems:** PR-00004 (Fascization — crisis mode), PR-00005 (Epistemic Power)
### PR-00003 — Performance Society Exhaustion
- **Models explaining:** MO-00001 (Han), MO-00002 (Fisher)
- **Values responding:** VA-00003 (Exhaustion Is Structural), VA-00004 (Mutual Aid Over Market)
- **Arguments:** —
- **Organizations:** —
- **Plans:** de-plan1-sven (CHALLENGE 4)
- **Related Problems:** PR-00001 (Meaning Crisis), PR-00004 (Fascization — exhaustion as entry condition)
### PR-00004 — Fascization
- **Models explaining:** MO-00002 (Fisher/Capitalist Realism), MO-00005 (Graeber)
- **Values responding:** VA-00002 (Authority Requires Justification), VA-00004 (Mutual Aid)
- **Arguments:** AR-00001 (Platform Feudalism → Democracy — structural precondition)
- **Organizations:** OR-00004 (Mehr Demokratie), OR-00003 (Reporter ohne Grenzen)
- **Plans:** de-plan1-sven (CHALLENGE 2 — authoritarian normalization)
- **Data:** DE-Democracy-Metrics (AfD vote share, "Wütende" segment)
- **Related Problems:** PR-00001, PR-00002, PR-00003, PR-00005
### PR-00005 — Epistemic Power Concentration
- **Models explaining:** MO-00003 (Foucault)
- **Values responding:** VA-00001 (Epistemic Sovereignty)
- **Arguments:** AR-00003 (Algorithmic Rationality Erodes Autonomy)
- **Organizations:** OR-00002 (Wikimedia), OR-00003 (Reporter ohne Grenzen), OR-00005 (netzpolitik)
- **Plans:** de-plan1-sven (CHALLENGE 1, STRATEGY 2)
- **Data:** DE-Democracy-Metrics (Press Freedom Index, EIU Democracy Index)
- **Related Problems:** PR-00006, PR-00007, PR-00004
### PR-00006 — Platform Feudalism
- **Models explaining:** MO-00003 (Foucault — epistemic control)
- **Values responding:** VA-00005 (Digital Autonomy Is Political)
- **Arguments:** AR-00001 (Platform Feudalism Threatens Democracy)
- **Organizations:** OR-00001 (IndieWeb), OR-00005 (netzpolitik)
- **Plans:** de-plan1-sven (CHALLENGE 3, STRATEGY 1)
- **Related Problems:** PR-00005, PR-00007
### PR-00007 — Knowledge Isolation
- **Models explaining:** MO-00004 (Vervaeke — participatory knowing)
- **Values responding:** VA-00006 (Deep Reflection As Practice), VA-00001 (Epistemic Sovereignty)
- **Arguments:** AR-00002 (PKM As Epistemic Sovereignty Strategy)
- **Organizations:** OR-00002 (Wikimedia), OR-00001 (IndieWeb)
- **Plans:** de-plan1-sven (CHALLENGE 5)
- **Related Problems:** PR-00005, PR-00006
---
## Models → Problems Addressed
| Model | Problems | Core Mechanism |
|-------|----------|----------------|
| MO-00001 Han (Performance Society) | PR-00001, PR-00003 | External discipline → internal drive → burnout |
| MO-00002 Fisher (Capitalist Realism) | PR-00001, PR-00003, PR-00004 | Inability to imagine alternatives enables authoritarian capture |
| MO-00003 Foucault (Power-Knowledge) | PR-00002, PR-00005, PR-00006 | Truth regimes as power relations; algorithmic epistemics |
| MO-00004 Vervaeke (Meaning Crisis) | PR-00001, PR-00007 | Collapse of participatory/perspectival knowing |
| MO-00005 Graeber (Anarchism) | PR-00002, PR-00004, PR-00006 | Domination must justify itself; prefigurative alternatives |
---
## Values → Problems Addressed
| Value | Problems | Core Claim |
|-------|----------|------------|
| VA-00001 Epistemic Sovereignty | PR-00005, PR-00007 | Right to own knowledge infrastructure |
| VA-00002 Authority Requires Justification | PR-00002, PR-00004 | Domination is begründungspflichtig |
| VA-00003 Exhaustion Is Structural | PR-00003, PR-00001 | Burnout is system output, not personal failure |
| VA-00004 Mutual Aid Over Market | PR-00001, PR-00002, PR-00003 | Cooperation as foundation, not competition |
| VA-00005 Digital Autonomy Is Political | PR-00006, PR-00005 | Own infrastructure = political act |
| VA-00006 Deep Reflection As Practice | PR-00007, PR-00001 | Participatory knowing requires deliberate practice |
---
## Arguments → Claims and Evidence
| Argument | Claim | Style | Key Premises |
|----------|-------|-------|--------------|
| AR-12934 | AIs are capable of understanding | Deductive | Functional vs. Experiential understanding |
| AR-00001 | Platform feudalism structurally threatens democracy | Deductive | Public sphere requires democratic structure; platforms are not neutral |
| AR-00002 | PKM is the best available epistemic sovereignty strategy | Abductive | Addresses root (no owned infrastructure), not symptoms |
| AR-00003 | Algorithmic rationality erodes autonomy invisibly | Causal | Foucault + Zuboff + Han: invisible epistemic shaping |
---
## Organizations → Problems and Strategies
| Organization | Primary Problem | Key Strategy | Plan Connection |
|-------------|-----------------|--------------|-----------------|
| OR-00001 IndieWeb | PR-00006 (Platform Feudalism) | Own your domain, open standards | de-plan STRATEGY 1 |
| OR-00002 Wikimedia | PR-00007 (Knowledge Isolation) | Free, open, collaborative knowledge | de-plan STRATEGY 2, 5 |
| OR-00003 Reporter ohne Grenzen | PR-00005 (Epistemic Power) | Press freedom as democracy indicator | de-plan CHALLENGE 6, STRATEGY 5 |
| OR-00004 Mehr Demokratie | PR-00002 (Domination) | Direct democratic instruments | de-plan MISSION, STRATEGY 4 |
| OR-00005 netzpolitik.org | PR-00005, PR-00006 | Digital rights journalism + advocacy | de-plan STRATEGY 1, 5 |
---
## Plans → Evidence and Components
### de-plan1-sven.md
- **Challenges map to:** PR-00001, PR-00002, PR-00003, PR-00004, PR-00005, PR-00006, PR-00007
- **Strategies use:** OR-00001, OR-00002, OR-00003, OR-00004, OR-00005
- **Grounded in Models:** MO-00001, MO-00002, MO-00003, MO-00005
- **Values:** VA-00001, VA-00002, VA-00005
- **Data:** DE-Common-Metrics, DE-Democracy-Metrics
### us-plan1-miessler.md
- **Author:** Daniel Miessler
- **Scope:** United States of America
- **Challenges:** Lack of shared identity, social cohesion, short political cycles
- **Data:** US-Common-Metrics, US-GDP, US-Inflation, US-Presidential-Approval
---
## Causal Chain (primary)
```
PR-00003 Exhaustion
→ PR-00001 Meaning Crisis
→ PR-00004 Fascization ← PR-00002 Domination (crisis mode)
↑
PR-00005 Epistemic Power
→ PR-00006 Platform Feudalism
→ PR-00007 Knowledge Isolation
```
**Key insight:** The causal chains converge on PR-00004 (Fascization) as the acute crisis — fed from above by meaning collapse and exhaustion, and from below by epistemic fragmentation. Structural responses must address both chains.
---
## Coverage Gaps (remaining empty directories)
| Directory | Status | Potential content |
|-----------|--------|-------------------|
| Solutions/ | Empty | Concrete solutions to PR-00001–PR-00007 |
| Ideas/ | Empty | Exploratory concepts, not yet solutions |
| People/ | Empty | Individuals working on these problems |
| Outcomes/ | Empty | Documented results from projects/experiments |
| Experiments/ | Empty | Active hypothesis tests |
| Projects/ | Empty | Ongoing initiatives |
| Claims/ | Empty | Specific factual claims (more granular than Problems) |
| Results/ | Empty | Data from completed experiments |
| Risks/ | Empty | Risks from plans or solutions |
| Threats/ | Empty | External challenges to plans |
| Frames/ | Empty | Mental models / worldviews |
| Funding-Sources/ | Empty | Funding for projects |
Reference in New Issue View Git Blame Copy Permalink